In this job, we make split-second decisions that carry lifelong consequences — for ourselves, for others, and for the communities we serve. The public doesn’t always understand what we see, what we carry, or what we’re asked or compelled to do. We operate in high-stress, high-stakes environments where the decisions we make can cost careers. Or lives.
Every day we walk a line; sometimes the line is clear, Sometimes it’s blurred. Our ethics guide that walk. Ethics isn’t about being perfect; it’s about making the best possible decision in the moment, for the right reasons. It’s about knowing where your moral compass points before you're in the heat of the moment. Here are some brief examples of ethical questions officers face every day:
Discretion vs. Duty
You could arrest someone — but should you? Would a warning work better? Are you enforcing the letter of the law or the spirit of it?
Loyalty vs. Integrity
What if a fellow officer cuts a corner, makes a bad call, or crosses the line? Are you willing to speak up — even if it puts you on the outs?
Force vs. Restraint
You’re trained to use force when needed — but also to know when not to. That balance isn’t always clear in the moment.
Public Service vs. Public Scrutiny
These days, everything we do can be recorded, judged, and broadcast. True ethics means doing the right thing even when no one’s watching.
Agency leadership has a lot of influence on how easily we are able to follow the right path. If the brass turns a blind eye, if toxic behavior is tolerated or if “just following orders” becomes the norm, it chips away at the foundation. Ethics has to be part of the department’s DNA — not just a line in the mission statement. You don’t just need a policy manual — you need role models. Mentors. Supervisors who back you when you make that tough but correct call. A chain of command that doesn’t just demand integrity — but lives it.
When officers cut corners, cover up, or abuse power, it damages more than their careers. It erodes public trust. And when trust is gone, safety suffers — for the community and for the officers who serve it. But when we do the right thing, consistently and visibly, something else happens: people start to believe in the badge again. And that’s a win for everyone.
Every officer knows what it means to walk the line. But not everyone talks about the mental, emotional, and ethical weight that comes with it. Doing the right thing in this profession takes courage — sometimes more than we give it credit for.
Ethics isn’t just a class at the academy. It’s not just a box to check during in-service training. It’s a daily decision. It’s what separates a badge from any other piece of metal.
Walk the line. Own your decisions. Lead by example. The job demands it — and the people we serve deserve it.
Lieutenant, Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office
ASP Trainer since 2015
Favorite ASP Tools: